StockSetups vs Trade Ideas
AI-backtested day-trading signals via the Holly engine.
Trade Ideas is a veteran scanning platform best known for Holly, its AI that backtests strategies overnight and surfaces live intraday signals the next session. To its real credit, Trade Ideas publishes a live trade log — losers included — which is one of the most honest track records in the category.
It's built for active day traders and runs roughly $127–254/mo (approx., as of mid-2026), Windows-first, with no real free trial and an all-sales-final policy. StockSetups takes a different shape: a $49 all-in plan that fuses the nightly scan, real-time alerts, AI ranking and alt-data into one per-symbol dossier, with a 7-day free trial and one-click cancel.
Side by side
| Trade Ideas | StockSetups | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | ≈ $127–254/mo (approx., mid-2026) | $49/mo flat — less on quarterly/annual |
| Trial & billing | No real trial; all sales final (crippled free 'Par' plan) | 7-day free trial, cancel in one click, free board forever |
| Daily pattern scan | Real-time scanning + Holly AI signals (day-trading focus) | ~12,300 US stocks & ETFs → 4 long lanes, conviction + trade plan |
| Real-time alerts | Real-time alerts — a core strength | 35+ intraday alert types — included, no add-on |
| AI ranking & 'why it's moving' | Holly AI backtested signals (deeper AI on Premium) | AI Smart Picks (Claude Opus) + AI catalyst — included |
| Congress / insider / Reddit / SEC | Not a focus — scanning/AI, not a fused alt-data dossier | All fused into one per-symbol dossier (incl. executive OGE) |
| Public track record | Publishes a live trade log incl. losers (the benchmark) | Forward-tracked Signal Report Card, win/loss shown |
| Charting | Functional; multi-window UI often called dated | Purpose-built setup charts (not a full TradingView-style studio) |
| Options flow | Not a focus | Not offered |
| Mobile app | Windows-first desktop | Web only — native app not yet |
Competitor pricing and features are approximate and as of mid-2026 — check their site for current details. We've tried to be fair; tell us if anything reads wrong.
Choose Trade Ideas if…
- You're an active day trader who wants an AI engine firing live intraday signals.
- You value Holly's overnight backtesting and a long, public live-results log.
- You're on Windows and live in a multi-window day-trading cockpit.
Choose StockSetups if…
- You want one flat $49 plan instead of $127–254/mo with AI gated to the top tier.
- You want pattern setups fused with fundamentals, congress/insider, Reddit, SEC filings and an AI catalyst per symbol — not just signals.
- You want a real free trial and to keep a genuinely useful free board.
Frequently asked
Is StockSetups a Trade Ideas alternative?
For swing and setup-focused traders, yes — it covers daily pattern scanning, real-time alerts and AI ranking in one $49 plan. Trade Ideas remains stronger for pure intraday AI signal generation via Holly.
See the difference yourself.
Full access to the scan, the tape and the dossier — free for 7 days, cancel in one click.
Start free — 7-day full access →